[2026 Edition] Shopify Loyalty App Comparison: 3 Recommended Choices
Shopify’s latest 2026 edition of loyalty apps plays a crucial role in the sustainable growth of e-commerce stores. As new customer acquisition costs soar, maximizing existing customer retention and customer lifetime value (LTV) is key to Shopify success. Deep customer engagement through points programs and VIP systems is essential. In this article, we’ve carefully selected three outstanding loyalty apps from the many available, providing a detailed ranking of their features, functionality, and user reviews. Using this comparison article as a reference, we’ll help you select the app that best suits your business model and support you in implementing a reliable customer loyalty strategy.
1st Place
LoyaltyLion
App URL: View on Shopify App Store
| Pricing | Free plan available. Paid plans start at $150/month. |
|---|
App Overview
LoyaltyLion is a data-driven loyalty and engagement platform. It helps ecommerce merchants accelerate growth and retain their loyal customers.
App Details
Create a loyalty program with customizable points, tiers, and rewards to fit your brand. Seamlessly integrate with marketing tools like Klaviyo to provide deep insights into customer behavior. Valued for its powerful segmentation tools for targeted campaigns, it offers sophisticated customer retention tools suitable for high-volume stores.
Reviews
After launching the points program, users reported seeing immediate results in repeat purchases. While setup can be complicated, the support team’s thorough guidance made implementation a smooth process. Users also praised the program’s integration with existing marketing tools and the usefulness of the resulting data.
The following are some user comments:
After launching the points program, we saw a remarkable increase in repeat purchases. Setup was a bit tedious, but the support team was incredibly helpful and guided us through everything.
Excellent integration with existing marketing stacks. The analytics dashboard provides actionable data for improving customer lifetime value. I highly recommend it for growing businesses.
The features are great, but the price is definitely on the high side. However, if you have a high volume of transactions and need sophisticated customer retention tools, it’s worth it.
I switched from a simpler app to LoyaltyLion for the increased customization options. My customers love the variety of ways they can earn points, not just for purchases.
2nd Place
Smile: Rewards & Loyalty
App URL: View on Shopify App Store
| Pricing | Free plan available. Paid plans start at $49/month. |
|---|
App Overview
Smile is a highly popular loyalty app for Shopify, offering points, referral, and VIP programs to turn one-time buyers into loyal, repeat customers.
App Details
It offers an intuitive interface for both merchants and customers. It allows you to quickly set up multiple campaigns, including rewarding points for signups and referrals, and establish VIP tiers. Known for its ease of use and affordability, it’s ideal for small businesses looking for a reliable retention tool. It features reliable back-end points management.
Reviews
It’s easy to start with a free plan and upgrade as you grow, and it’s highly rated for its ease of use. The referral system is particularly excellent, and has proven to drive new traffic and increased sales. Support responses are often fast and helpful.
The following are some user comments:
The free plan was perfect for getting started. As I grew, upgrading was easy, and the features expanded appropriately. It’s very user-friendly.
The referral system is fantastic! It’s helped drive a lot of new traffic and purchases. Support responses are usually fast and helpful.
I struggled to get the design customizations to fit perfectly with the theme, but the backend works perfectly. Point management is very reliable.
3rd Place
Yotpo Loyalty & Rewards
App URL: View on Shopify App Store
| Pricing Structure | Free plan available. Custom pricing available for larger businesses. |
|---|
App Overview
Yotpo Loyalty & Rewards is part of the Yotpo Integration Platform, helping you build lasting relationships with your customers through customizable loyalty and referral programs.
App Details
Deeply integrated with Yotpo’s other solutions (reviews, SMS marketing), it provides seamless data integration. Design sophisticated campaigns, including VIP tiers and milestone rewards, though customization may require some technical knowledge. Centralized data management is a significant benefit for stores already using other Yotpo products.
Reviews
Integrating with Yotpo Reviews is highly effective, and users appreciate the fact that all customer data is centralized, simplifying marketing. While setting up complex VIP logic takes time, users say it’s highly effective once implemented. Support responses are prompt, but often routine.
The following are some user comments:
Integrating with Yotpo Reviews works extremely well. Having all customer data in one platform has significantly reduced marketing efforts.
Powerful features, but setting up the complex VIP logic took longer than expected. Once up and running, it’s very effective.
Support is fast, but often boilerplate. The app itself is robust enough to effectively manage points and rewards.
